Skip to content

Opinion: Is the Catholic Church Open to Life?

I am now writing about a subject that has receded – if not into oblivion – at least into the background. In 1968, Pope Paul VI published the encyclical Humanae vitae, in which he reaffirmed the Church’s teaching on family planning: artificial contraception, such as hormonal contraception, condoms and sterilisation, is morally wrong, but natural family planning may be used if there are “valid” reasons for spacing births. It is important to note that natural family planning should not be taken for granted either. Rather, it involves spouses examining their reasons together before God. In the encyclical, welcoming children and openness to life are, instead, the starting point of the vocation to marriage.

Natural family planning means observing the fertile and infertile phases of a woman’s menstrual cycle through signs of fertility. These signs include, for example, basal body temperature and changes in cervical mucus during the cycle. By observing fertility signs, it is possible to determine the approximate time of ovulation, when the likelihood of conception is highest. It is also possible to identify the infertile phase of the menstrual cycle, when research indicates that sexual intercourse is very unlikely to result in pregnancy. The effectiveness of natural family planning when used correctly is approximately 98–99%.

Natural family planning does not, therefore, alter the bodily functions of either the man or the woman, as happens, for example, with sterilisation or a hormonal intrauterine device. The underlying idea is that God has created the bodies of men and women in such a way that marital union can naturally lead to the conception of new life, provided the timing is favourable and there is no illness or disability preventing it. Natural family planning seeks to respect this natural order.

From a medical perspective, natural family planning is a fairly reliable method of avoiding pregnancy, provided that those using it have received appropriate instruction, which in practice means training and support. The method can also be used to increase the likelihood of conception when a couple hopes for another child. Natural family planning requires self-control and ongoing communication, which has in fact been found in many cases to improve the quality of the relationship. Many couples have also reported in studies that practising natural family planning has improved both their relationship and – interestingly – their sex life. Families practising natural family planning are also larger on average, which may be interpreted as reflecting a change in attitudes towards welcoming children.

The Gap Between Teaching and Practice

It must nevertheless be acknowledged that natural family planning has not been a success within the Catholic Church. As a method of family planning, it is generally practised just as rarely among Catholic married couples as among the population as a whole (approximately 1–3%). According to studies, Catholic couples statistically use the same artificial methods of contraception as the general population, even though these methods are considered wrong according to Church teaching.

It has been said that there is a “crisis of teaching” on this subject. Lisa and Magnus Wetterberg expressed the matter at a seminar organised by KatSote on 3 October 2026 by saying that the Church has failed pedagogically in teaching about this issue. The statistics are, in this respect, even dramatic. Birth rates have collapsed even in traditionally Catholic countries such as Italy and Spain. Of course, there are also voices within the Catholic Church calling for the teaching on this matter to be changed to bring it more into line with the “spirit of the times”. I doubt that this will happen, but in my view the consequence has largely been silence on the subject.

For several years, I have had the opportunity to teach about this subject at marriage preparation courses in various Catholic parishes. In practice, natural family planning cannot be learnt in such a short time, but it is nevertheless good that the subject is covered before marriage. In this way, couples at least gain some knowledge of how, according to Church teaching, they should approach welcoming children and being open to life. But what happens to these married couples afterwards? Where do they receive support in using the method? What about when challenges arise and their strength is running low? Keeping the door open to new life is a heavy cross to bear, since prevailing social values largely point in the opposite direction. It is therefore quite easy to conform and choose a different path.

It has been suggested that the teaching of Humanae vitae is an ideal that can rarely be put into practice, and that it is therefore not such a serious matter if artificial contraception is used. In my opinion, recognising gradual growth is a good starting point in the Christian life. In many respects, we are not yet fully formed, and we need grace, which is not only forgiveness but also strength for a new life. However, there is a difference between striving towards something – even if we sometimes fail – and ceasing to strive altogether. The teaching of Humanae vitae on family planning expresses the Church’s understanding of how marriage and sexuality can be lived in the happiest way. It teaches that the deepest happiness can only be found when we give ourselves to loving within marriage as Christ loved the Church – by giving himself completely.

Within the Catholic Church, there are some groups that have been more successful in this respect. One such group is the Neocatechumenal Way, founded by Kiko Argüello and Carmen Hernández. In Finland, there are an unusually large number of families with many children within the movement. What is their secret? I would suggest that it is teaching, close community life and support. Members gather with their communities several times a week and receive support in their vocation, including their vocation to marriage. There are also longer gatherings involving overnight stays and shared community life, while continuous catechesis forms the foundation of everything. Children are also taken into account at gatherings, and childcare is often available.

These structures are familiar – with the necessary adjustments – from, for example, the Conservative Laestadian revival movement within the Evangelical Lutheran Church, where birth rates have remained relatively high, unlike in society at large.

How Can the Church Better Support Married Couples?

But what could the Catholic Church learn from these movements? How could we live more faithfully according to Humanae vitae? The first step is to recognise the challenge. If the Church does not actively present the position of Humanae vitae on family planning, married couples will make different choices in accordance with prevailing social values. Looking at the statistics, a marriage preparation course and an occasional passing mention of the subject in a homily are not sufficient.

In addition, follow-up courses for Catholic married couples could be organised several times a year, along with family and marriage weekends, for example. Perhaps the activities of the Neocatechumenal Way could also be integrated more effectively and extensively throughout the diocese. These initiatives could foster community, social support and a strengthening of the vocation to marriage. If the issue is recognised as important, providing resources for such activities should be at the top of the agenda.

In Finland, the Catholic Church appears to be the fastest-growing Christian denomination. This is largely due to immigration and Christians from other denominations who have converted to the Catholic faith. In Western and Southern Europe, the situation can be quite different: churches have to be sold as congregations have dwindled. Vocations to the priesthood have also declined, and even in Finland we can speak of a shortage of priests. An adequate birth rate and children are critically important for the continuity of society. They are equally important for the future of the Church.

“Children are a gift from the Lord, the fruit of the womb is his reward.” (Ps. 127:3)

Miikka Nummenpää
Physician
Saint Ursula Parish

Share the article in social media:


Other topics